4 Comments
User's avatar
Martin D. Brown's avatar

Quite by luck on Monday I was invited to a screening with a Q&A afterwards with Edward Berger (Director); Nick Emerson (Editor); Lisy Christl (Costume Designer); Suzie Davies (Production Designer); Volker Bertelmann (Composer); Ben Baird, C.A.S (Sound Designer and Re-Recording Mixer); Nina Gold (Casting) and Martin Ware (Casting)...I am usually quite sceptical of these things but was interesting, especially the sound design, the breathing and the clothing -- they refused to use costumes from the Young Pope as they looked cheap, also about the coffee machines and the photocopier...I liked it more than the book.

Dion Georgiou's avatar

I enjoyed the film a lot, even if I thought its presentation of Vatican politics as metaphor for politics more broadly meant something was lost in terms of understanding religion and faith as a thing in and of itself, with its own intellectual dynamics

Martin D. Brown's avatar

Yeah, it was really good, I enjoyed it a lot. But I liked the Young Pope too, or the first series anyway, the second I gave up on, apparently Berger is now doing a film about gambling in Macau

Lisa Rull's avatar

I thought this was a very good film and we really enjoyed it, far more political than I expected but I can also see how that might diminish the specifics of religion and its organisation.

As much as I love Tucci, I actually thought his performance was rather unbalanced: or perhaps it was the character which felt rather unmoored? Either way, I didn't think Aldo's candidacy felt especially viable.

But the work of the Sisters, led by Isabella Rosselini was beautifully portrayed: their mundane activities ensuring these men were fed and watered, with spaces to sleep (and bags of toiletries to battle with) was very well depicted.

I thought the sound design was particularly excellent - and watching it in a relatively small screening space it felt appropriately claustrophobic to have such focus on the breath. There was an audible gasp near the end and I was actually more thrilled and touched by those scenes than I would have expected. Solid recommend!